The Ocean Equity Index is flawed, misleading, and lacks validation
The Ocean Equity Index (OEI)[1] is a newly proposed framework conceived as a rapid assessment of ocean initiatives with respect to their “status and progress toward” social equity, allowing for comparison across regions via a quantitative score. The Index, presented as a sum of twelve criteria scored between zero to three, is presented as a “standardized and transparent approach for measuring ocean equity”; yet, its construction is highly flawed, its scores are misleading and, rather than measuring equity, its application will further delegitimize incidents of inequity that do not fit the OEI’s scoring scheme. Given the pitfalls of standardized indices undermining the struggles for social justice and environmental conservation[2], we urge the authors to critically reassess their approach to indexing ocean equity and refrain from further application of the OEI.
